Gainesville & North Central Florida real estate, personally guided
All posts

November 13, 2026

I Inherited a House in Gainesville. What Should I Do First?

First: I'm sorry. Nobody inherits a house without also losing someone, and you're being asked to make property decisions while you're still grieving.

Here's what I tell everyone in your spot: you don't have to decide anything this week. Not whether to sell, keep, rent, or renovate. The house isn't going anywhere, and the order you do things in matters far more than the speed.

I'm Sarah Garrigues-Jones, a Seniors Real Estate Specialist® who has called Gainesville home since 1970. This is the order I'd walk you through.

Step 1: Breathe, then secure the house

Before paperwork, make sure the house is safe.

  • Change or re-key the locks if people you don't know well have keys.
  • Check that the water heater, A/C, and roof aren't actively causing a problem. In Florida, a closed-up house plus humidity gets ugly fast.
  • Keep the A/C running. Mold doesn't wait for probate.
  • Forward the mail and set a reminder to check on the house weekly.
  • Take photos of every room before anyone moves anything. You'll want them later for the estate, for insurance, and for family peace.

Step 2: Call the insurance company

This is the one most people miss. Many homeowner policies limit or end coverage once a home sits vacant for a stretch of time, and the policyholder is gone. Call the agent, explain what happened, and ask what the policy does now and whether you need a vacant-home policy. Verify your exact vacancy window with your specific carrier. It varies by policy.

Step 3: Find the will (and know where it goes)

If there's a will, find the original. In Florida, whoever has the original will is generally required to deliver it to the Clerk of Court after the person dies.

If there's no will, that doesn't mean disaster. It means Florida law decides who inherits, and you'll need an attorney.

Step 4: Talk to a Gainesville probate attorney before you list, sell, or sign anything

I'm a real estate agent, not an attorney, and I'll say so every time. Who has the legal authority to sell the house depends on how the property was titled, whether there's a will, and whether probate is needed. A good local estate attorney will tell you that in one conversation. A few things to ask about:

  • Who is (or will be) the personal representative, and what can they legally sign?
  • Is probate required for this property? Florida has special rules around homestead property.
  • Was there a survivorship deed or other arrangement on the title?

I keep a list of attorneys, contractors, and clean-out help I trust, and I'm happy to share it. I don't take referral fees for sending you to the right people, and I don't need your business to do it.

Step 5: Get the house valued, but not just by a Zillow number

Whether you sell or keep it, you'll want to know what it's worth as of the date of death. That number matters for taxes. In general, inherited property gets a "stepped-up" tax basis, which often means far less capital gains tax than people fear. Verify with a CPA, since your situation may differ. A CMA is a good start, but a formal appraisal is what your attorney or CPA may ask for. I can help with the first and point you toward the second.

Florida also has no state inheritance tax. Verify your current status with your attorney or CPA before you rely on it.

Step 6: Understand what happens to the property taxes

If the house had a homestead exemption, that doesn't automatically carry over to you. When ownership changes, the "Save Our Homes" cap on assessed value generally resets, so the tax bill can jump. Check with the Alachua County Property Appraiser's office so you aren't surprised.

Then there's Amendment 3, which Florida voters approved on November 3, 2026. It raises the homestead exemption from $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, and it passed with about 62% of the vote. Three things to know if you've inherited a house:

  • It only helps if the house is homesteaded. Qualifying homeowners will pay property taxes on a smaller portion of their home's value, but it won't make the whole bill disappear. If you're keeping the house and moving in, it can matter. If you're selling, it mostly won't.
  • School taxes aren't included. School district property taxes stay under the existing rules, and 2026 tax bills aren't affected.
  • If you're keeping it as a second home, the new rules are different. Starting January 1, 2027, the annual assessment cap for non-homestead property, including second homes and rentals, drops from 10% to 5%.

Also, if you're an out-of-state heir planning to move into the house, an owner who hadn't maintained a permanent Florida residence as of December 31, 2026 gets only the $50,000 exemption until the fifth year of exemption.

Read the full Amendment 3 explainer from CBS12

Note: results are unofficial until certified, and details may change as the legislature implements Amendment 3.

Step 7: Talk to your siblings or co-heirs, early

The house is rarely the hard part. It's the three kids, one house, two states, and a lifetime of unspoken stuff about who got what.

Before anyone talks listing price, try to agree on three things:

  1. Do we want to keep it, sell it, or buy someone out?
  2. Who's handling day-to-day decisions, and how often do we update each other?
  3. How do we handle the contents? Everyone will want different things, usually not the ones you'd guess.

If it gets tense, that's normal. A neutral third party (your attorney, or me, in the real estate part) can lower the temperature.

Step 8: Decide what's staying and what's going, slowly

Don't rent a dumpster on day three. Go room by room, and use categories: keep, family, donate, sell, toss. Don't forget the places people hide things: freezers, books, coat pockets, and the junk drawer with an envelope of cash in it.

For donations and furniture, Gainesville has options, including estate-sale companies and the local Habitat for Humanity ReStore.

Step 9: Then decide: sell, keep, or rent

Now you have the facts: what it's worth, what the carrying costs are (taxes, insurance, utilities, upkeep), what the legal situation is, and what your family actually wants.

  • Sell as-is: Often the simplest if the house needs work or you live out of town. You'll likely net less than a polished sale, but you also skip months of repairs.
  • Fix up and sell: Makes sense when a few targeted updates will move the price. Condition tells the story. I'll show you the actual Gainesville comps so you can see what updates are worth it and which aren't.
  • Keep it: Fine, if you want to and can afford to. Just run the real carrying costs first.

(I don't handle rentals, so if that's your direction, I'll happily point you to someone who does.)

Step 10: Choose an agent who gets your situation

An inherited sale isn't a normal sale. You may be selling from another state, with multiple decision-makers, on a legal timeline, and with a house full of someone's life. Look for an agent who:

  • Listens before pitching
  • Has experience with estates and senior transitions
  • Explains things in plain English and doesn't rush you
  • Will actually tell you what the house is worth, even when it isn't what you hoped

That's how I work. Everyone's story is different, so I'd rather hear yours first.

If you've just inherited a Gainesville house and you're staring at the keys wondering where to begin, send me a message. No pressure and no pitch, just a free, no-obligation conversation about where things stand. And if someone you know is going through this right now, feel free to send them this post.

Sarah Garrigues-Jones, REALTOR®, SRES® | BHHS Florida Realty | sarah@sarahgjrealtor.com | 352-359-5600

The newsletter

Get new posts in your inbox

Occasional emails when something new is published — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Guiding You Home.

Questions about a Gainesville-area move? Sarah is one call away.

Call 352.359.5600

Get Local Updates

Seasonal guides, local events, and what's happening in Gainesville, delivered to your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to receive emails from Sarah Garrigues-Jones, REALTOR®. Unsubscribe anytime.